Putting youth-in-the-loop after the Milburn review

Josephine Hansom considers what Alan Milburn’s call for youth participation means for brands, clients, agencies and the way we research young people’s lives.

young people waiting for tube London

If, like me, you’ve worked in youth research for the past 20 years, you will have watched youth participation swing in and out of fashion.

In the mid-2000s, it was an industry essential and baked into Every Child Matters frameworks, Connexions panels and local commissioning briefs. As budgets tightened and behavioural economics became the new shiny thing, participation became a nice-to-have and we leaned harder on big data, longitudinal tracking and rapid online panels.

Tuesday’s publication of Alan Milburn’s report, From a Welfare State to a Working State, brings youth participation back into view. Regardless of where anyone sits on the politics of welfare reform, one sentence in the report should make every research director and insight lead sit up: “Youth participation will run through public policy like a stick of rock.”

For those of us who translate young people’s lives into evidence, this isn't a nostalgic return to the mid-2000s. This is a vision of a different future and an invitation to build on the strong evidence base our industry already has, so that our practices keep pace with young people’s lives.

The review puts the scale of the challenge at nearly one million 16-to-24 year-olds not in education, employment or training (Neet). It reports that seven in 10 Neet respondents surveyed want to work or train, while more than 300,000 ‘hidden’ Neets are outside the benefits system. The scale of these numbers is concerning and shows that more, not less, research is needed in this area.

For years, research has done valuable work tracking young people’s choices, attitudes and outcomes, but it has sometimes missed their lived meaning. Even a standard label like ‘Neet’ can flatten reality: as one young person put it, they weren't avoiding education, employment or training… they were desperate for it. Evolving our practice means centring young people in how we define the issues from the very start, rather than retrofitting the lives of young people into our existing boxes.

Which brings us to what we should call this next era of practice. Borrowed shamelessly from AI engineering, we need ‘youth-in-the-loop’.

In machine learning, ‘human-in-the-loop’ exists for a pragmatic reason: when an algorithm runs on historical data without continuous human calibration, it drifts, amplifies bias and hallucinates solutions for a world that no longer exists.

Research workflows can face a similar risk. Clients and research teams scope the brief, write the questions, analyse the data and interpret why a 19-year-old walked away from a training scheme at week six. When youth voice is brought in only for an upfront focus group or a wrap-up workshop, even rigorous findings risk drifting from lived reality.

“Even a standard label like ‘Neet’ can flatten reality: as one young person put it, they weren't avoiding education, employment or training… they were desperate for it.”

Putting ‘youth-in-the-loop’ means moving away from using young people as PR ambassadors at the end of a project and bringing them in as genuine sense-makers where it counts most. In practice it looks different on every project, whether it is pressure-testing the brief before fieldwork starts, helping us read between the lines of the data or reality-checking our recommendations before they land on a client’s desk.

As Milburn’s blueprint moves from innovative ideas, like local youth opportunity services, and the youth opportunity test to future policy design, the implications for our industry are concrete:

  • Moving beyond one-and-done research: Clients will increasingly look for continuous feedback loops built into delivery, like Milburn’s stick of rock, rather than relying on single-moment surveys. Testing ideas and spotting friction with young people early helps teams adjust in real time, avoiding expensive missteps down the line.
  • Reaching the lost generation: With nearly half of surveyed Neets reporting a long-term health condition, the review is a reminder that young people are not a monolith and rarely need the same things. Even well-designed samples can struggle to reach those facing the biggest hurdles, pushing co-designed recruitment and peer research from optional extras into essential practice.
  • Raising practitioner standards: If ‘youth participation’ becomes a requirement in research tenders, our sector must guard against box-ticking. That means establishing clear industry benchmarks for compensating, training and safeguarding peer researchers, without turning a small pool of articulate insiders into professional youth voices who are detached from their peers.

Two decades ago, we argued for youth participation on moral grounds. Today, understanding young people’s lives means looking for their ambition and opportunity, instead of benchmarking the present against a past that only adults know.

Josephine Hansom is the co-founder of Now & Next

We hope you enjoyed this article.
Research Live is published by MRS.

The Market Research Society (MRS) exists to promote and protect the research sector, showcasing how research delivers impact for businesses and government.

Members of MRS enjoy many benefits including tailoured policy guidance, discounts on training and conferences, and access to member-only content.

For example, there's an archive of winning case studies from over a decade of MRS Awards.

Find out more about the benefits of joining MRS here.

0 Comments


Display name

Email

Join the discussion

Newsletter
Stay connected with the latest insights and trends...
Sign Up
Latest From MRS

Our latest training courses

Our new 2025 training programme is now launched as part of the development offered within the MRS Global Insight Academy

See all training

Specialist conferences

Our one-day conferences cover topics including CX and UX, Semiotics, B2B, Finance, AI and Leaders' Forums.

See all conferences

MRS reports on AI

MRS has published a three-part series on how generative AI is impacting the research sector, including synthetic respondents and challenges to adoption.

See the reports

The only place...
to become an AI expert

Training

Conferences

Reports

Programmes